Noble Caledonia Hebridean Sky

Cathy Bartrop joined a cruise on board Noble Caledonia’s Hebridean Sky and here considers the advantages of small ship cruising.

How small is a small ship? In 2018, the world’s current largest cruise ship, Symphony of the Seas, was launched carrying up to 6680 passengers. I guess compared to that, anything under 1000 passengers could be considered small. So a ship like the Hebridean Sky (along with sister ships Caledonian and Island Sky) with a maximum capacity of just 118 guests can justifiably be categorised as TINY.

Noble Caledonia's Hebridean Sky The experience on board a ship of this size is completely different to most people’s concept of a cruise. It’s a bit like comparing a stay in a family run boutique hotel with an all-inclusive, international resort complex. In other words, there is no comparison, it’s chalk and cheese. Many guests I spoke to on board Hebridean Sky recoiled in horror at the thought of cruising on a mega liner – a few had tried it, the vast majority would not dream of it. All on this ship, bar a handful of first timers, were loyal repeat passengers – one lady on board had clocked up no less than 37 cruises across the three Sky ships. So, what is it about small ship cruising that keeps them coming back.

Topping the list for most passengers is the social aspect – these cruises attract ‘like- minded’ people – in other words, affluent, extremely well-travelled, largely retired professionals. The age range fluctuates depending on the physical demands of the cruise itinerary – longhaul and expedition cruises which involve zodiac excursions will naturally be slightly younger, but the average age tends to be somewhere between 65 and 75. These are most definitely not party ships and that is also part of the appeal. The entertainment comes largely from interaction with each other. Age aside, you meet all sorts of people, from all walks of life, often with fascinating life stories to share and always, regardless of age, with a lust for life.

Noble Caledonia's Hebridean Sky Within a matter of days, faces become familiar and the conversation flows… and flows. Whether you are travelling solo or as a couple, single sitting but open dining means that you share all meals with a constantly circulating selection of guests. Over time, groups of new friends form but generally, if you prefer splendid isolation, I would suggest this is not the the type of cruise for you!

Of course, the size of the ship also dictates the extent of the facilities. On board Hebridean Sky, the Club Bar, the Lounge and both the interior restaurant and al fresco dining deck are the main gathering points. Aside from eating and drinking entertainment is limited to the background of a pianist in the bar, the occasional quiz or, if you happen to have a Cruise Director with a talent, they will most likely do a ‘turn’ at some stage. On our cruise, cruise director Neil Horrocks turned his 20 years working at sea into an hilarious evening of anecdotes. There may be a small group of night owls keeping the barman busy until late, but the vast majority are happy with dinner, possibly a few drinks afterwards and bed. There is also a strong educational bent to this type of cruise – the lectures, designed to either reflect the theme of the cruise or share specialist knowledge, are always well attended.

Many passengers also have a keen interest in all things nautical and love observing operations coming in and out of ports. An open bridge policy allows them to inspect charts and chat freely with the captain and his crew. For more nautical types, the ‘motion of the ocean’ is also apparently a joy! These ships do not have the sophisticated stabilisers of their larger peers. On the plus side, small ships are nimble and the itineraries are designed for flexibility, should you run in to bad weather. I am not saying it will never be rough but when it is, usually, it is short lived.

Noble Caledonia's Hebridean Sky If you do feel like escaping, your options are to find a quiet spot out on deck or retreat to your cabin. No hardship, the cabins are lovely – more spacious than you might imagine, comfortable, well equipped and immaculately maintained by housekeeping. Cabins on the upper two decks have balconies – always a bonus in fine weather and an extra bit of privacy.

In truth though, there isn’t masses of time to idle away – the nature of the itineraries mean you arrive somewhere new every day. Sea days are rare, generally you will cruise in the evening and overnight, arriving early in to port next day, ready to set off on another adventure.

Which brings me on to the perhaps the biggest advantage of small ship cruising – the small ports they can access. In these days of over tourism, the seasoned traveller is often looking to experience something different, away from the crowds. That is not to say you won’t visit any larger ports but, even when you do, small ships have the advantage of squeezing in at the front, closer to the centre of town. The ability to be quickly off the ship and head straight off on an excursion or sightsee independently, makes a big difference to maximising your time ashore. It also means that often the welcome is surprisingly warm. On this cruise for instance, one of our ports of call in Portugal was the picturesque fishing port of Figuera da Foz – it was the first time the Hebridean Sky had had been there and they were clearly pleased to see us. On our return to the ship, we even given a gift each of a goody bag containing a T-shirt and sample of the local salt.

Coimbra, Portugal The excursions are all included in the cruise price. There will be at least one half-day trip per day, sometimes two and occasionally a full day with lunch ashore. Excursions are not compulsory of course but the vast majority do take them. When a drive is involved there will generally be three coaches, each accompanied by a local guide as well as a member of the Noble Caledonia team. From Figuera da Foz we took the short drive to Coimbra – home to Portugal’s oldest and surely most beautiful university campus. Our well organised visit in small groups included not only a tour of the key buildings but, because of our limited numbers and, by special permission from the Dean, access to the extraordinary and priceless Joanina Library.

The nature of the beast (and marketing spend) mean that small ship cruises do not seem to get anywhere near the same number of column inches as the big cruise lines. As a result, many ‘new to cruise’ passengers still seem to have an idea that all cruise ships are equal – in fact, these days, nothing could be further from the truth. Through my video work, I hold my hand up to having experienced perhaps more than my fair share of cruises, both big and small. The success of the choice depends very much on your stage of life, your interests and what type of things you like to do on a holiday. Both have their pros and cons but the experience for sure is entirely different. If it is size alone that is putting you off the idea of a cruise, my advice is to think small – I think you might be pleasantly surprised.


Silver Travel Advisor recommends Noble Caledonia.
334 people found this helpful

Share Article:

Cathy Bartrop

Travel writer & vlogger

Leave a comment


Sign up to our newsletter to receive the latest travel tips on top destinations.

Join the club

Become a member to receive exclusive benefits

Our community is the heart of Silver Travel Advisor, we love nothing more than sharing ideas, inspiration, hints and tips between us.

Most Recent Articles

Mark Nicholls visits Austria’s snowiest ski resort and stumbles across a chapter of pop history….

Come feel the love on a Princess cruise. You’ll enjoy the MedallionClass experience others simply can’t, and it’s exclusively for everyone. Visit incredible destinations and be involved in the best experiences around each one of them.

Experience more with Princess and connect effortlessly with the world around you, spend time away with loved ones, take a moment for yourself, and fall in love with your holiday of a lifetime, every time.

With over 20 years of experience, Wendy Wu Tours has mastered the art of creating exceptional, fully inclusive tours which showcase the very best of each destination.

Each tour is led by a world-class guide, who will highlight the very best of their homeland, and includes authentic cultural experiences so you are not just seeing the sights, but truly immersing yourself in local life.

Say hello to ease at sea. Ambassador’s purpose is simple: they want to inspire every guest to experience authentic cruising, effortlessly and sustainably. Passionate about protecting our oceans and destinations, their ships comply with the highest industry emission standards and there is no single-use plastic on board.

On your voyage, you will receive the warmest of welcomes from the Ambassador community as you sail upon the friendliest ships afloat.

This is a global co-operative co-owned by local partners using real local experts and guides, which supports local communities, environments and wildlife. It offers travellers quirky places to stay, activity holidays and learning experiences. Not In The Guidebooks gets travellers off the beaten track into local culture with day experiences and longer, immersive adventures.

From wild wellness breaks in Wales to painting in Portugal, sustainable adventures in Mauritius to food safaris in Brazil, this is immersive, exciting travel.

Seabourn’s five intimate ships carry guests to the heart of great cities, exclusive yacht harbours and secluded coves around the world, while two new purpose-built expedition ships will combine exhilarating adventures in remote destinations with the sophisticated amenities of the world’s finest resorts at sea.

From the luxury of all suite accommodations to complimentary fine wines and spirits, and a no tipping policy, Seabourn exemplifies the definition of travelling well.