Simply Italian

875 Reviews

Star Travel Rating


Review type

Things to do


Date of travel

September, 2021

Product name

Simply Italian

Product country


Product city


Travelled with

Reasons for trip

“Simply Italian”: in Rye does what its name implies: simple Italian food.

Arriving at 8pm for our mid-week reservation, the restaurant was buzzing. We were shown to a table on the ground floor but before we got settled in, I realised that open doors at the back and front of the restaurant meant we’d be sitting in a through draught. I asked if we could be moved which wasn’t a problem and we were shown to a mezzanine floor up a flight of stairs.

Rather than having a starter each, we shared a garlic bread and were given the option of a small, saucer sized one or large dinner plate size. We were glad we went large as the thin crisp pizza with its buttery garlic juices and smells, was quickly devoured.

We chose our two favourite pasta dishes: spaghetti carbonara and lasagne. Both were good and offered with generous servings of grated parmesan and black pepper.
Service from the largely young crew was very friendly and professional and although I was tempted by a pudding or coffee, I was really too full.

With a litre of a palatable house white, reasonable at £21, our bill came to £48.05 with service charge not being automatically added.

This is a casual place and as it’s relatively cheap, was obviously popular with family groups. It also makes a change from Rye’s many fish restaurants.

There is also a branch in Eastbourne.

Helen Jackson

Join the club

Become a member to receive exclusive benefits

Our community is the heart of Silver Travel Advisor, we love nothing more than sharing ideas, inspiration, hints and tips between us.